clm-7d6413e05f439d23
descriptive
Germany's first diesel driving ban
Permanent project revision
Revision 2026-08-28-claims-and-dates · effective 2026-08-28
Superseded. A later revision exists: 2026-08-28-story-claims →
Completed the claim array, corrected two source dates, and replaced three passages the sources do not carry: a percentage we had derived ourselves, an editorial absolute about automated enforcement, and a compliance sentence that hid the station's two measuring heights disagreeing in 2019.
sha256:e49c2ddfbef0af7f952b9be8d1a47f25a98dc4ffad79c7193f1aba50b9346cfb
replace /snapshot/projectFingerprint — Updated projectFingerprint to the current sourced project record.replace /snapshot/asOf — Updated asOf to the current sourced project record.replace /snapshot/claims — Updated claims to the current sourced project record.replace /snapshot/sources — Updated sources to the current sourced project record.The text below is copied verbatim from the published record. Each claim names the source dossiers that carry it; caveats stay attached to the claim they qualify.
clm-7d6413e05f439d23
descriptive
Germany's first diesel driving ban
clm-38eea77c0e0e9e17
quantitative
from 31 May 2018 two Altona street sections barred pre-Euro-6 diesels
clm-5445f3efefbf36eb
quantitative
580 m of Max-Brauer-Allee (cars and trucks) and 1.6 km of Stresemannstraße (trucks only)
clm-e48ae5fdbe57bd66
descriptive
Enforcement was manual police document checks, never cameras
clm-dca6c5b6a59240a9
quantitative
Hamburg lifted both in September 2023 after NO2 fell below the 40 µg/m³ limit
clm-0117847199fea9f9
quantitative
exceeded the 40 µg/m³ EU annual limit from 2012 to 2016
clm-954bbbb6c25974a0
quantitative
stood at 28 µg/m³ in 2025
clm-42ed9ab4fd091821
quantitative
the limit was met from 2019 to 2022
clm-9e919284ae021109
quantitative
the station's own reading at the 1.5 m breathing-zone intake was still 41 µg/m³ in 2019, just above the limit, while the 4 m intake read 38
clm-ebe7eff359d31895
quantitative
estimated roughly -6.9 µg/m³ against control stations
clm-f58b0e6178d67064
quantitative
estimates swing between -4 and -11.7 µg/m³ depending on the comparison period and control group chosen
clm-e8457cb7b475e88a
descriptive
even the authors caution that fleet changes and the clean-air plan's other measures may inflate the estimate
clm-5af08e3baa6dd77e
descriptive
a continuous monitoring station
clm-fb10a7aa365503ac
quantitative
a binding 40 µg/m³ limit
clm-03da137838c18aa9
descriptive
a court order
clm-51745d4b17796e42
descriptive
an officer waving a car to the kerb to read its registration papers
clm-ff3c31bb01427694
descriptive
because a German licence plate does not encode the Euro class
clm-ecf5f5bfb3a3d0fc
descriptive
the blue windscreen badge that would have marked compliant diesels was never introduced
This layer records what is known about each source, what is still missing, and the exact snapshot this page is rendering. A missing date, archive or hash stays visible as missing.
Awaiting operator and domain-expert review; publication of this revision implies neither.
sha256:e49c2ddfbef0af7f952b9be8d1a47f25a98dc4ffad79c7193f1aba50b9346cfb
src-f138f8ec45a7afd6Official notice: both driving restrictions lifted 13 September 2023 after an expert assessment forecast permanent limit compliance without them.
src-78983a575e95aae2Court ruling upholding the restriction as lawful, with case background.
src-1eda123f8c5e7044Official monitoring station description, operating since 2002.
src-5ad10b6668b18d1bAnnual NO2 mean values by year, including the 2025 reading.
src-5abb6c67e3c52aeeIndependent evaluation; central estimate ~-6.9 µg/m³ but flags wide sensitivity to model choice.
src-4a6db2a33aa030b2Contemporary press coverage of manual police enforcement.
src-00e8a7eb0a4220cfIndependent EU confirmation of the ban as Germany's first implemented diesel access restriction.
src-22a7eb1ac48afd89The Federal Administrative Court's press release on the Leipzig judgments that made street-level diesel bans legally possible, with proportionality conditions (phased introduction, no Euro-5 bans before 1 September 2019, exemptions for tradespeople and residents).
src-9087fc9835d4acb5dpa report on the day the ban took effect, with the environmental groups' criticism: Greenpeace and BUND called the two-street scheme symbolic.
src-f39f2801655b84baContemporary report with the CDU criticism ('reine Symbolpolitik für die grüne Klientel in Altona') and the 272-residents-relieved versus thousands-on-diversion-routes figures.
src-77b177ad6e3ad19cThe environmental association's one-year balance: the truck ban on Stresemannstraße cut the rolling annual mean from 47 to 41 µg/m³, Max-Brauer-Allee barely moved; BUND blamed lax checks and demanded the never-introduced 'Blaue Plakette' windscreen badge. Fetch quirk: the host answers a browser user-agent with 403 and a plain curl UA with 200.
src-fb87becc8d274a68Official 2017 annual data of the Hamburg air monitoring network: Max-Brauer-Allee 46 µg/m³ NO2 (down from 58 in 2016), Stresemannstraße 48 — both still above the limit, before the ban existed.
src-5baa308f7de9069bOfficial 2018 annual data ('Stand: Juni 2019'): in the ban's first calendar year all four traffic stations still exceeded the limit; Max-Brauer-Allee held at 46 µg/m³ — and the network itself attributes the low 2017 baseline to construction-related traffic rerouting, not to policy.
src-820abfe0c0eb0dd9Official 2019 annual data ('Stand: April 2020'): Stresemannstraße met the annual limit for the first time in both measuring heights; Max-Brauer-Allee complied at 4 m (38 µg/m³) but was 'just above' at the 1.5 m breathing-zone intake (41 µg/m³).
src-1557d67191fea8bfOfficial 2020 annual data ('Stand: Mai 2021'): NO2 annual means Max-Brauer-Allee 36 µg/m³, Stresemannstraße 34 µg/m³ (1.5 m) — first full year below the limit at both banned sections.
src-d6981697e9974e31Official 2021 annual data (corrected edition, 'Stand: Juli 2022'): Max-Brauer-Allee 34 µg/m³, Stresemannstraße 33 µg/m³.
src-19cd79c541d303a0Official 2022 annual data ('Stand: März 2023'): Max-Brauer-Allee 31 µg/m³, Stresemannstraße 32 µg/m³.
src-483b5cb6f30e86a4Official 2023 annual data table (uncommented; states no publication date — date null is a finding, the PDF CreationDate is a production artifact): Max-Brauer-Allee 30 µg/m³, Stresemannstraße 33 µg/m³ — the year the bans were lifted.
src-3d000137dfaec224Official 2024 annual data table (uncommented, 'endgültige Daten'; states no publication date): first full year after the lifting — Max-Brauer-Allee 27 µg/m³, Stresemannstraße 30 µg/m³, both well below the limit.
src-05ab120fda203970The federal Environment Agency's machine-readable annual NO2 balance (continuously served API, states no publication date). For 2019 it reports 41 µg/m³ for station 846 (DEHH070, Hamburg Max-Brauer-Allee II) and 40 µg/m³ for station 802 (DEHH026, Stresemannstraße) — the federal record of the contested 2019 value. Year parameter selects other years of the same series.