1001 Smart Cities

Permanent project revision

BA Elige: Buenos Aires's Online Participatory Budget

Revision 2026-08-27-editorial-review · effective 2026-08-27

Current revision. This is the snapshot used by the live entity page.

unreviewed

Rewrite a source note that told the reader how the page answered a request instead of what it carries.

sha256:f0923a99de2e5bfc95f9db6b2c79be2e9f61ea0bffd425f77220fa29b3bd7ff7
All revisions → Current entity page →

Change set

  • replace /snapshot/projectFingerprint — Updated projectFingerprint to the current sourced project record.
  • replace /snapshot/sources — Updated sources to the current sourced project record.
10
of 10 claims mapped
9
source dossiers
6
publication dates recorded
0
archives linked
0
exact locators
0
content captures hashed

Claims, one by one

The text below is copied verbatim from the published record. Each claim names the source dossiers that carry it; caveats stay attached to the claim they qualify.

Claim 1 clm-2d8f7309fffcb4e1 quantitative
From 2017 Buenos Aires ran BA Elige on Consul, the open-source participation platform Madrid released in 2015, letting residents propose and vote on neighbourhood works
Published field
snippet · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
The OECD entry: 'the Madrid City Council developed the CONSUL software and launched it in Madrid under the name Decide Madrid in 2015', and names Buenos Aires among the 100-plus authorities using it. Agencia Paco Urondo dates the Buenos Aires launch to April 2017.
Caveat
No claim-specific caveat recorded

Sources carrying this claim

  1. OECD Observatory of Public Sector Innovation — Consul Project
  2. Agencia Paco Urondo — 'BA Elige: el proyecto que eligieron los vecinos y que el gobierno porteño no realizará'
Claim 2 clm-95731a34206da424 quantitative
The city's own dataset records three editions — 2017, 2018 and 2019 — across which website visits fell from 6.4 million to 1.59 million and winning projects dropped from 443 to 108
Published field
snippet · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
The city open-data resource covers 2017, 2018 and 2019 only, with columns for web visits, registered users, proposals, supports, votes and winning projects: visits 6.4M in 2017 against 1.59M in 2019, winners 239 (2017), 443 (2018) and 108 (2019).
Caveat
The dataset page is a JavaScript shell for an automated client, so no locator string could be recorded; the figures were read from the resource on 26 July 2026.

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Buenos Aires Data — Participación Ciudadana: BA Elige (city open data)
Claim 3 clm-289476a1567d6856 descriptive
Opposition legislators and communal board members argued the programme routed around the comunas
Published field
snippet · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
Legislator Adrián Camps calls BA Elige “el BA elige es una forma de puentear todas la actividad de las comunas, de establecer una forma de presupuesto participativo manejado directamente desde el poder ejecutivo sin participación de los vecinos”; communal representatives Zicolill and Suarez say the mechanism can be manipulated by political operators.
Caveat
The manipulation charge is an allegation by named critics; no specific case is evidenced, and none is asserted here.

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Nadie Nos Invito — 'Se conocieron las 15 propuestas más votadas del BA Elige y crecen los cuestionamientos'
Claim 4 clm-413287d399cd8e7d quantitative
whose consultative councils Ley 1777 gives a role in a budget the city constitution already declares participatory
Published field
snippet · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
At the Ombudsman's 2025 event marking 20 years of Ley 1777, the coordinator of the inter-council communal body states that the participatory budget the law provides for was never implemented.
Caveat
No claim-specific caveat recorded

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Defensoría del Pueblo CABA — '20 años de la Ley de Comunas'
Claim 5 clm-92cbc6785963edeb descriptive
The platform is now gone: its domain no longer resolves
Published field
snippet · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
The programme site was fetched on 26 July 2026 and DNS resolution failed (ENOTFOUND). The citation is retained precisely because its disappearance is the finding.
Caveat
No claim-specific caveat recorded

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Programme site (defunct) — baelige.buenosaires.gob.ar
Claim 6 clm-a68aa674621b4678 descriptive
the city never published a completion record for the projects residents voted for
Published field
snippet · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
The resource carries no execution or completion field, and the companion programme dataset is listed as historical with no regular updates planned.
Caveat
No claim-specific caveat recorded

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Buenos Aires Data — Participación Ciudadana: BA Elige (city open data)
  2. Buenos Aires Data — Programa BA Elige dataset
Claim 7 clm-4ccc7ff5cbfd7f91 quantitative
analysing the 2018 cycle, Annunziata finds the winning projects tend to be more general than those chosen in face-to-face participatory budgeting, and attributes the shift to the technical possibilities of the institutional design rather than to deliberation among participants
Published field
impact · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
The abstract: 'La conclusión advierte que las propuestas seleccionadas tienden a ser más generales que en los Presupuestos Participativos “cara a cara”, aunque esto resulta menos de la deliberación o del intercambio entre los participantes que de las posibilidades técnicas presentes en el diseño institucional.'
Caveat
No claim-specific caveat recorded

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Annunziata, R. (2020), 'El impacto de los Presupuestos Participativos online en el tipo de proyectos: un análisis de la experiencia de BAElige', Revista del CLAD Reforma y Democracia
Claim 8 clm-3a0e11053dc70e1b descriptive
The city's own dataset carries no execution or completion field
Published field
impact · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
The city open-data resource lists web visits, registered users, proposals created, supports, votes and winning projects — and nothing about what was delivered.
Caveat
No claim-specific caveat recorded

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Buenos Aires Data — Participación Ciudadana: BA Elige (city open data)
Claim 9 clm-5674e52d50c4ed8b quantitative
a Comuna 5 plaza declared a winner on 21 September 2017 — was removed from the published winners list five days later, the city saying it had no jurisdiction over the land
Published field
impact · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
Agencia Paco Urondo, 27 September 2017: on 26/09/2017 the Participación Ciudadana office telephoned the resident who had proposed the plaza to say the project 'es inviable, ya que no tenemos jurisdicción sobre el terreno', apologised, and then deleted it from the published winners page.
Caveat
One documented case, not a rate; nothing supports generalising from it.

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Agencia Paco Urondo — 'BA Elige: el proyecto que eligieron los vecinos y que el gobierno porteño no realizará'
Claim 10 clm-d01bdca366657cb3 descriptive
A participation platform can document its turnout in fine detail and its delivery not at all — then disappear, taking the record with it
Published field
lesson · verbatim
Mapping
mapped · no interpretation or interpolation added by this passport
What the mapping says
The city published visits, users, proposals, supports, votes and winners for three editions and no completion data at all; the companion dataset is marked historical; and the platform's own domain no longer resolves.
Caveat
No claim-specific caveat recorded

Sources carrying this claim

  1. Buenos Aires Data — Participación Ciudadana: BA Elige (city open data)
  2. Buenos Aires Data — Programa BA Elige dataset
  3. Programme site (defunct) — baelige.buenosaires.gob.ar

Source dossiers and revision state

This layer records what is known about each source, what is still missing, and the exact snapshot this page is rendering. A missing date, archive or hash stays visible as missing.

unreviewed Revision 2026-08-27-editorial-review effective 2026-08-27 · created 2026-08-27

Awaiting operator and domain-expert review; publication of this revision implies neither.

sha256:f0923a99de2e5bfc95f9db6b2c79be2e9f61ea0bffd425f77220fa29b3bd7ff7
Revision history → Permanent version link → Machine-readable record → Evidence Constitution →
10
of 10 claims mapped
9
source dossiers
6
publication dates recorded
0
archives linked
0
exact locators
0
content captures hashed

Governance facts carried by the record

Operator
Gobierno de la Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires
Actor types
city-government
Funding model
public
Funding description
City of Buenos Aires budget
Cost
Not recorded
Ownership
Not recorded
Decision rights
Not recorded
Exit conditions
Not recorded

9 source dossiers

Buenos Aires Data — Participación Ciudadana: BA Elige (city open data) data.buenosaires.gob.ar · 4 linked claims

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-3b40aa97198d2020
Publisher
Name not classified · data.buenosaires.gob.ar
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
Not recorded
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

Authoritative city resource, fetched 2026-07-26. Columns cover web visits, registered users, proposals created, supports, votes and winning projects. Covers 2017, 2018 and 2019 only — no later edition appears. Web visits fall 6.4M (2017) to 1.59M (2019); 2019 records 28,098 proposals and 108 winning projects, against 239 winners in 2017 and 443 in 2018. Carries no execution or completion field. No publication date is recorded for this page.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
Buenos Aires Data — Programa BA Elige dataset data.buenosaires.gob.ar · 2 linked claims

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-ddddc38fd0c98c7d
Publisher
Name not classified · data.buenosaires.gob.ar
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
2021-05-10
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

Gender-ratio dataset for the programme, published 10 May 2021. Update frequency is listed as historical, with no regular updates planned — the city's own signal that the programme is closed.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
Annunziata, R. (2020), 'El impacto de los Presupuestos Participativos online en el tipo de proyectos: un análisis de la experiencia de BAElige', Revista del CLAD Reforma y Democracia ri.conicet.gov.ar · 1 linked claim

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-bc962192587006a1
Publisher
Name not classified · ri.conicet.gov.ar
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
Not recorded
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

Peer-reviewed, July 2020. Analyses the 2018 cycle and finds selected projects 'tend to be more general than in the face-to-face participatory budgeting', attributing the shift to platform design rather than citizen deliberation. Explicitly does NOT measure whether winning projects were built — which is why the entry carries no impact figure.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
Nadie Nos Invito — 'Se conocieron las 15 propuestas más votadas del BA Elige y crecen los cuestionamientos' nadienosinvito.com.ar · 1 linked claim

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-7e161d0dbbfbfddc
Publisher
Name not classified · nadienosinvito.com.ar
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
2017-07-18
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

18 July 2017. Carries the comunas counterweight: legislator Adrián Camps calls BA Elige 'a way to bypass all the activity of the communes… participatory budgeting managed directly from the executive power without participation of neighbours through communal consultative councils'. Communal representatives Zicolill and Suarez say the mechanism 'can be easily manipulated by political operators'. Supports the bypass claim in the snippet; does not evidence any specific manipulation case, so none is asserted.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
Agencia Paco Urondo — 'BA Elige: el proyecto que eligieron los vecinos y que el gobierno porteño no realizará' agenciapacourondo.com.ar · 2 linked claims

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-f60d471017e277ec
Publisher
Name not classified · agenciapacourondo.com.ar
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
2017-09-27
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

Single documented case of a winner not built: a Comuna 5 plaza declared a winner on 21 Sept 2017, told five days later it was 'inviable, ya que no tenemos jurisdicción sobre el terreno', then removed from the published winners list. One case, not a rate — the entry does not generalise from it.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
OECD Observatory of Public Sector Innovation — Consul Project oecd-opsi.org · 1 linked claim

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-66fa87e32fffa09a
Publisher
Name not classified · oecd-opsi.org
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
2015-11-20
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

Independent confirmation of the Consul lineage: platform originally developed for the Madrid city government, adopted by 100+ institutions across 30+ countries, with Buenos Aires named among the municipalities using it.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
Defensoría del Pueblo CABA — '20 años de la Ley de Comunas' defensoria.org.ar · 1 linked claim

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-afeddc88bfa221f6
Publisher
Name not classified · defensoria.org.ar
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
2025-09-03
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

2025 event marking 20 years of Ley 1777. Rubén Daniel López, coordinator of the Inter-Council Communal Consultative Council, states the participatory budget was never implemented — the constitutional backdrop against which BA Elige was an executive-run substitute.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
El Auditor — 'Una iniciativa busca habilitar el presupuesto participativo en la Ciudad de Buenos Aires' elauditor.info · background

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-5257615a9e6eb9a9
Publisher
Name not classified · elauditor.info
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
2024-02-16
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

Bill to create a commune-level participatory budget in CABA, describing it as the second time such a programme would exist and referencing BA Elige's 2017 launch — corroborating that no participatory budget currently runs in the city. Gives no end date for BA Elige.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
Background source; no baseline claim points here
Programme site (defunct) — baelige.buenosaires.gob.ar baelige.buenosaires.gob.ar · 2 linked claims

Open original source ↗

Stable source ID
src-be8ec9455ba00c5d
Publisher
Name not classified · baelige.buenosaires.gob.ar
Type / language
web-page · language not classified
Published
Not recorded
Updated
Not recorded
Source last checked
No source-level check date
Record last verified
2026-08-27
Dossier created
2026-08-27
Retrieved copy
No local capture recorded
Archive
No archived copy linked
Content hash
No captured content hash
Locator
Open the recorded source note

The programme's own site, which no longer resolves. It is kept as the primary-source citation for the platform itself; the most recent Internet Archive capture is 7 June 2023, and everything this entry states about BA Elige is carried by the sources beside it. No publication date is recorded.

Descriptive only — not page/paragraph exact
Claims linked
Known limits of this passport
  • Publisher names and source languages have not yet been classified; domains are recorded without guessing.
  • Existing source notes are descriptive locators, not page- or paragraph-exact citations.
  • A missing archive, publication date or content hash is shown as null rather than inferred.
  • The project-level evidence grade ranks the strongest source in the entry; it is not a truth score for every claim.